My grandmother's " Be an Artist at the gas Range 1935" Mystery Chef calls scotch scones " exceedingly delicious and inexpensive to make". because the 1935 recipe does NOT use butter or shortening. Just 1 cup of leftover milk, sweetened or soured. My mother and grandmother cooked the scone squares over a coal wood stove. So, I combined the two recipes with Oat Cream and plant butter to come up with this......baked in a preheated 425 degree oven.
Combine the 2 eggs with Oat Cream and mix.
Mix all dry ingredients together. Line baking sheet with a silpat baking liner or parchment paper. Do not grease.
Plop cut up pieces of plant butter, or margarine, into dry ingredients, blend with pastry cutter.
Combine quickly, as if making pastry. Should just be brought together till it looks barely holding together.
Divide into two balls of dough and gently pat into rounds on baking sheet.
"Wax paper will preserve food. Every kitchen should have a box of wax paper.." -The Mystery Chef, 1935
Sprinkle with a bit of coarse sugar, or a small amount of plain granulated sugar. It's not for flavour but to give interest to the tops.
(John MacPherson, a Scottish chef , came to the US in 1906. He had an interesting life, and in the 1930's started a series of radio shows called 'The Mystery Chef'. He ended up having 63 sponsors and tons of listeners. He believed cooking should be for everyone. His tv cooking show in 1949 lasted only one year. He was the "Mystery Chef' with a secret identity! )
Back to the Scones......Cut the rounds into six triangles. Bake in hot 425 degree oven about 15 minutes. I watch them carefully. Bake another 6 minutes. Put a piece of foil on top. Check the centers. Cut triangles again to separate a little to help them finish baking. Bake about 4 or 5 more minutes until a knife inserted into the scones comes out clean.
"Guesswork has been replaced by certainty in the automatic gas range, refrigerator, water heater and house heating unit..." -The Mystery Chef, 1935
Photographs 2025